Whether you’re a seasoned veteran coach or just getting started in your coaching career, the way you motivate your clients can make a substantial difference in their progress and, ultimately, their lives.

But what’s the best way to foster motivation? Is it through external rewards and punishments, or should we focus on nurturing our clients’ internal drives and passions?

Motivation is broadly categorized into two types: intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic motivation is the internal drive that compels an individual towards self-improvement, personal growth, or satisfaction from achieving a goal. Extrinsic motivation, on the other hand, originates from external factors such as rewards, punishments, or recognition.

In this post, we’ll explore the differences between these two critical theories of motivation while also showing how you can leverage them in a coaching setting. We’ll also demonstrate how life coaches can blend these approaches to improve their practice and empower their clients to reach their full potential.

What Is Motivation Theory?

Motivation theory includes a variety of psychological models and theories that seek to understand what drives individuals to act or behave in specific ways. These theories aim to explain why we have particular desires, how we set goals, and why we persevere in achieving them despite obstacles.

But why is motivation important?

Different individuals are motivated by different factors. Some may be driven by intrinsic motivation, while others respond more to extrinsic rewards or incentives. By understanding motivation theories, coaches can tailor their approach to each client’s motivational drivers.

Incentive Motivation Theory

The incentive motivation theory posits that behavior is driven by a desire to gain rewards or avoid punishments. Key to this theory is the concept of incentives — external stimuli that either encourage or discourage certain behaviors.

For example, a bonus at work (reward) might inspire you to take on extra projects, while the prospect of a speeding ticket (punishment) may deter you from driving too fast. These external factors or incentives can greatly influence our decisions and actions.

The Incentive Motivation Formula

Reward + Time Investment = Performance2

The incentive motivation theory provides a framework for understanding and influencing behavior through manipulating external rewards and punishments.

What Are Motivational Incentives?

Motivational incentives are external stimuli that either encourage or discourage certain behaviors.

What Are Examples of Positive and Negative Incentives?

Positive incentives are rewards. Negative incentives are punishments. For example, a bonus at work (positive/reward) might inspire you to take on extra projects, while the prospect of a speeding ticket (negative/punishment) may deter you from driving too fast. These external factors or incentives can greatly influence our decisions and actions.

diagram of motivational incentives at work

Intrinsic Motivation Theory

Intrinsic motivation theory emphasizes the internal drives and passions that motivate our actions. This theory proposes that people are motivated by internal rewards such as satisfaction, self-improvement, and the joy of mastering a skill.

Examples of intrinsic motivation can be seen in a musician who practices relentlessly out of love for music or a runner who trains daily to enjoy feeling strong and healthy. These internal drives are personal and subjective but vary among individuals.

Intrinsic motivation impacts behavior by sparking a deep, personal commitment to a task or goal. When intrinsically motivated, we engage in an activity for its own sake, not external rewards. This leads to greater enjoyment, increased effort, and better performance. Research suggests that intrinsic motivation is often linked to long-term success and well-being, highlighting its importance in personal development and growth.

What’s the Difference Between Incentive and Intrinsic Motivation?

Incentive and intrinsic motivation theories offer perspectives on what drives human behavior. 

The incentive theory shows us that external rewards or punishments guide our actions. In contrast, intrinsic motivation theory suggests our actions stem from internal drives, such as personal satisfaction, passion, or the joy of accomplishment.

Incentive motivation works best for short-term behavioral changes; the carrot or the stick drives us to action. However, intrinsic motivation theory is crucial for long-term engagement and personal fulfillment; the internal fire keeps us going even when external rewards are absent.

Relying solely on one theory can have pitfalls. If you overemphasize external rewards, your client’s interest will diminish once the reward is removed. On the other hand, if you rely exclusively on intrinsic motivation, your client will feel that not every action is necessarily rewarding. So, be sure to balance these theories to benefit from both immediate action and long-term engagement.

sparklers to represent how motivational incentives can light a spark within

What Types of Rewards Are Motivating?

Our internal motivations influence which external motivations resonate with us. All external rewards are nice — who doesn’t enjoy being praised or getting an unexpected bonus? But some incentives will especially build us up because they connect with our inner drives.

  • For example, a person who’s driven to finish projects will appreciate team celebrations that recognize successful completion of an initiative. This finisher may like being in charge of a project so that they can set the pace to the finish line and ensure the project is not abandoned. 
  • A person with a strong drive for mastery will appreciate opportunities for professional development and being assigned key roles on unique projects that require a specific skill set which they already possess or can develop. 
  • An individual who is internally motivated by collaboration will appreciate incentives that capitalize on teamwork and camaraderie such as networking events, professional conferences, and team celebrations.

To optimize incentives with your clients, you need to know what motivates them internally. Learn more about how intrinsic motivations affect external rewards at Motivation Code. The MCode uncovers what makes someone tick and reveals the incentives that will resonate most deeply with them.

Using Incentive Motivation in Business Coaching

As a business coach, understanding and applying certain motivation strategies will significantly impact your clients’ workplace. This approach leverages external rewards to boost motivation, engagement, and ultimately, productivity.

Use the following strategies to help your clients build an employee incentive program that is mutually beneficial.

1. Recognition and Praise

Recognizing and praising an employee’s efforts will create a sense of value and accomplishment. We commonly refer to this as positive reinforcement; it drives motivation and productivity. Regular shout-outs in team meetings or a simple ‘well-done’ email will go a long way toward boosting morale.

2. Career Advancement Opportunities

Show your business coaching clients how to provide clear paths for promotion and growth to significantly motivate their employees. Knowing their hard work leads to increased responsibilities and upward mobility will fuel drive, determination, and a stronger work ethic.

3. Skill Development Initiatives

Encourage continual learning through training programs or workshops to enhance employee capabilities and confidence. This shows investment in their growth, making them more motivated, engaged, and productive.

4. Flexible Work Arrangements

Be flexible with work schedules and remote work options to improve work-life balance. This understanding and flexibility will incentivize employees to maintain high productivity levels and job satisfaction.

5. Performance-Based Bonus

Monetary rewards based on performance are strong motivators. Employees will strive to exceed expectations when their efforts are rewarded with bonuses, raises, or profit-sharing opportunities.

6. Team Celebrations

Celebrating team successes creates a sense of collective achievement. Whether it’s a project completion or reaching a sales target, celebrations will incentivize teams to work collaboratively and productively.

7. Professional Networking Opportunities

Facilitate access to networking events or industry conferences to enhance an employee’s professional growth. Knowing their organization supports their industry engagement will incentivize them to excel.

8. Personal Development Support

Provide resources for personal growth, like wellness programs or counseling services, to show your organization cares for its employees beyond their professional roles. This incentivizes higher job satisfaction and motivation levels.

9. Special Projects or Assignments

Offering opportunities to work on challenging and stimulating projects is a powerful incentive. It breaks the monotony and enables employees to stretch their skills and find new areas of interest.

10. Employee Benefits

Offer attractive benefits packages, such as health insurance, retirement plans, or flexible spending accounts, to provide security and increase job satisfaction. Such benefits will incentivize employees, making them feel valued and motivated to contribute to the organization’s success.

A white mug, filled with black coffee sits on a light wood grain surface. On the mug is a single word: BEGIN.

Using Incentive Motivation in Life Coaching

In life coaching, using incentive motivation strategies will boost a client’s drive toward personal growth and success. Here are some incentive motivation techniques you can use to encourage and support clients on their journey.

1. Goal Achievement Rewards

Celebrating goal achievement with rewards, such as a small treat or personal indulgence, is a simple, but powerful motivator. This approach makes the journey towards personal growth more enjoyable, reinforcing the positive behavior that leads to success.

2. Positive Affirmations

Use positive affirmations to significantly boost self-confidence and motivation. By encouraging your clients to maintain a positive mindset, you’ll help them overcome self-doubt and face challenges with renewed enthusiasm.

3. Accountability Partnerships

Pair clients with accountability partners or support groups to foster a sense of community and responsibility. Knowing that others can count on them will motivate your clients to stay on track and achieve their goals.

4. Personalized Action Plans

Tailored action plans, designed to meet each client’s unique needs and aspirations, provide a clear path to success. This clarity and personalization significantly enhances motivation and drive.

5. Progress Tracking Tools

Tools like habit trackers or goal-setting apps provide clients with a visual representation of their progress. Seeing their progress represented visually is a powerful incentive to stay consistent and motivated.

6. Time Management Strategies

Effective time management enhances productivity, but also provides a sense of accomplishment. Assist your clients in developing these skills to boost their motivation and help them make the most of their time.

7. Mindfulness and Self-Care Practices

Encourage your clients to prioritize self-care and mindfulness to improve their overall well-being. When clients feel mentally and physically healthy, they’re more likely to be motivated to pursue their personal growth goals.

8. Recognition and Celebration of Achievements

Acknowledge and celebrate every win — no matter how small — to reinforce positive behavior. This recognition incentivizes your clients to continue striving for their goals.

9. Inspirational Resources

Recommending books, podcasts, or TED Talks that inspire and motivate can be a valuable source of ongoing motivation. These resources provide clients with fresh perspectives and strategies for success.

10. Personalized Feedback and Support

Provide your clients with constructive feedback and ongoing support throughout their coaching journey to significantly boost their motivation. Knowing they have a supportive coach to guide them gives clients the confidence to face challenges head-on.

Free Printable List of Motivational Incentives for Coaches

Always look for ways to personalize these motivational incentives to each client’s unique needs and motivational drivers. What works for one client may not necessarily work for another.

The key lies in balancing these strategies, combining the power of both intrinsic and incentive motivation to build an environment that truly empowers clients to reach their goals.

Coach Factory Icon

Written by The Coach Factory Team

We're a team of coaching enthusiasts who hire and work with coaches. Members of our team run businesses in the coaching industry or provide services that support coaches, and several of us are coaches ourselves.

Become a Coach Factory Member Today for FREE!

Get instant access to our growing library of tools, training, insights, and resources you need to elevate your coaching game... completely free. No upsells. No gimmicks. Free forever!


SEO for Life Coaches: How to Get Found by the Clients Who Need You

50 Blogging Topics for Business Coaches